This ice cream was so sickly sweet I ate two bites and tossed the rest. The texture is nice but the artificial marshmallow flavor is so bad I couldn’t eat it.
Rated 5 out of 5
Thomas –
Good treat. Good and sweet.
Rated 3 out of 5
lydia –
Soooo sweet, and not many chunks of sponge candy. The texture is good and creamy though. Up the oomph by sprinkling on some flaked salt.
Rated 1 out of 5
DF –
Wow. I’ve never met a bowl of ice cream I did not want to finish, until Okie Dokie.
The candy gets stuck in your teeth. It is overwhelmingly sweet and unenjoyable.
This is the first new product from TJ’s I’ve ever been grossed out by, and they do some very experimental things!
Rated 1 out of 5
Rob –
Great texture, terrible synthetic flavor.
Rated 4 out of 5
Christopher McDonald –
A nice ice cream to have available, as a vegan. It is a little on the too-sweet side, but the crunchies and the caramel swirls are nice.
Rated 5 out of 5
Sam W. –
I can see where people are coming from about how sweet it is, but personally, I loved it. The texture is amazing – much creamier than Trader Joe’s vegan vanilla ice cream (the one made with almond milk), and probably the best dairy-free ice cream texture I’ve had from any Trader Joe’s frozen desserts.
The caramel swirl is good, but my favorite part is the spongey candy bits. So satisfying and delicious to crunch into a bite that has those little pieces in it.
I may or may not have eaten the pint in one sitting…
Rated 5 out of 5
Diane –
This a wonderful ice cream . If you’ve ever had a crunchie bar this is the ic cream equivilant! If you don’t like sweet things then don’t eat ice cream
Rated 5 out of 5
Chloe E –
I love the review that said, if you don’t like sweet things than don’t eat ice cream lol. That’s exactly how I feel! This ice cream was excellent in my opinion. So nice to finally have a dessert option at TJ’s that doesn’t contain soy and is vegan. Which is rare. I thought the flavor was delicious and the caramel and candy pieces were a yummy unexpected treat within a treat!
Rated 5 out of 5
Anonymous –
I grew up eating sponge candy and this was such a nice treat especially being non-dairy! I pray to god it doesn’t get discontinued
Rated 4 out of 5
Nicole –
Loved it! Finally a ice cream that isn’t made of dairy but actually taste good. It can be sweet but that means I won’t eat as much at one time. I need to gain weight , this might help!
Rated 3 out of 5
Katie T –
Good texture, not great taste. Taste very artificial caramel, and the oat base taste like stale oat milk? I never leave reviews but this was so disappointing I had to lol.
Rated 1 out of 5
kermit –
the ice cream taste itself is very artificial and overly sweet, it’s pretty gross honestly. the texture is good though.
Rated 4 out of 5
Suzy –
Yes it’s too sweet. Yes it tastes oddly like cool whip. But it’s also kinda delicious.
Rated 1 out of 5
Gene –
The container is nice but that’s it. The flavor is nondescript.
Rated 5 out of 5
Mary English –
Please keep this forever! Non-Dairy Queen
Rated 5 out of 5
Bob –
Okie Dokie is great. Since I have issues with milk and would rather not eat a pill to have ice cream Okie Dokie is great. Great flavor, creamy texture and yes there are hard pieces of candy in it, it they taste great.
Rated 5 out of 5
Anonymous –
Delicious, I understand where other people are coming from that it is very sweet, but the light texture of the ice cream is one of the best of all the non-dairy ice cream brands I’ve tried. I also enjoy the spongey bits of candy.
Rated 1 out of 5
Mickey –
I had to throw it out. First time I’ve ever trashed a TJ product. The texture of the oat milk ice cream is okay, but the candy bits are terrible. The wrong kind of crunchy, they get stuck in your teeth, and don’t taste good to boot.
Rated 5 out of 5
Devon –
I loved this non-dairy sweet treat that feels like I’m eating ice cream. I love the taste and can’t wait to buy more.
And I will as I live so close. I ate the whole container. I’ll have to decide to eat one serving, and not the whole thing.
Rated 3 out of 5
Helena –
If only the honeycomb bits were more evenly distributed! I agree that this can be overly sweet, if you get a spoonful with too much of the caramel swirl. However, there are plenty of opportunities to have some of the ice cream base with no inclusions at all. IMO, there are too many bites without honeycomb, but the ones that do have candy (and the right amount of caramel)…delicious.
Also, suffers from being a pint, when it should be a quart.
Rated 5 out of 5
Dorothy –
Cannot eat dairy, love this dessert. Please bring it back.
Anonymous –
This ice cream was so sickly sweet I ate two bites and tossed the rest. The texture is nice but the artificial marshmallow flavor is so bad I couldn’t eat it.
Thomas –
Good treat. Good and sweet.
lydia –
Soooo sweet, and not many chunks of sponge candy. The texture is good and creamy though. Up the oomph by sprinkling on some flaked salt.
DF –
Wow. I’ve never met a bowl of ice cream I did not want to finish, until Okie Dokie.
The candy gets stuck in your teeth. It is overwhelmingly sweet and unenjoyable.
This is the first new product from TJ’s I’ve ever been grossed out by, and they do some very experimental things!
Rob –
Great texture, terrible synthetic flavor.
Christopher McDonald –
A nice ice cream to have available, as a vegan. It is a little on the too-sweet side, but the crunchies and the caramel swirls are nice.
Sam W. –
I can see where people are coming from about how sweet it is, but personally, I loved it. The texture is amazing – much creamier than Trader Joe’s vegan vanilla ice cream (the one made with almond milk), and probably the best dairy-free ice cream texture I’ve had from any Trader Joe’s frozen desserts.
The caramel swirl is good, but my favorite part is the spongey candy bits. So satisfying and delicious to crunch into a bite that has those little pieces in it.
I may or may not have eaten the pint in one sitting…
Diane –
This a wonderful ice cream . If you’ve ever had a crunchie bar this is the ic cream equivilant! If you don’t like sweet things then don’t eat ice cream
Chloe E –
I love the review that said, if you don’t like sweet things than don’t eat ice cream lol. That’s exactly how I feel! This ice cream was excellent in my opinion. So nice to finally have a dessert option at TJ’s that doesn’t contain soy and is vegan. Which is rare. I thought the flavor was delicious and the caramel and candy pieces were a yummy unexpected treat within a treat!
Anonymous –
I grew up eating sponge candy and this was such a nice treat especially being non-dairy! I pray to god it doesn’t get discontinued
Nicole –
Loved it! Finally a ice cream that isn’t made of dairy but actually taste good. It can be sweet but that means I won’t eat as much at one time. I need to gain weight , this might help!
Katie T –
Good texture, not great taste. Taste very artificial caramel, and the oat base taste like stale oat milk? I never leave reviews but this was so disappointing I had to lol.
kermit –
the ice cream taste itself is very artificial and overly sweet, it’s pretty gross honestly. the texture is good though.
Suzy –
Yes it’s too sweet. Yes it tastes oddly like cool whip. But it’s also kinda delicious.
Gene –
The container is nice but that’s it. The flavor is nondescript.
Mary English –
Please keep this forever! Non-Dairy Queen
Bob –
Okie Dokie is great. Since I have issues with milk and would rather not eat a pill to have ice cream Okie Dokie is great. Great flavor, creamy texture and yes there are hard pieces of candy in it, it they taste great.
Anonymous –
Delicious, I understand where other people are coming from that it is very sweet, but the light texture of the ice cream is one of the best of all the non-dairy ice cream brands I’ve tried. I also enjoy the spongey bits of candy.
Mickey –
I had to throw it out. First time I’ve ever trashed a TJ product. The texture of the oat milk ice cream is okay, but the candy bits are terrible. The wrong kind of crunchy, they get stuck in your teeth, and don’t taste good to boot.
Devon –
I loved this non-dairy sweet treat that feels like I’m eating ice cream. I love the taste and can’t wait to buy more.
And I will as I live so close. I ate the whole container. I’ll have to decide to eat one serving, and not the whole thing.
Helena –
If only the honeycomb bits were more evenly distributed! I agree that this can be overly sweet, if you get a spoonful with too much of the caramel swirl. However, there are plenty of opportunities to have some of the ice cream base with no inclusions at all. IMO, there are too many bites without honeycomb, but the ones that do have candy (and the right amount of caramel)…delicious.
Also, suffers from being a pint, when it should be a quart.
Dorothy –
Cannot eat dairy, love this dessert. Please bring it back.